Subscribe to our Daily Digest e-mail
Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe Outraged at Senator McCaskill’s Attempt to Abrogate Sovereign Immunity

The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe issued the following statement today in response to legislation introduced by U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill (D-MO) that seeks to abrogate tribal immunity from being asserted in the Inter Partes Review proceedings on the tribally owned patents for RESTASIS® (Cyclosporine Ophthalmic Emulsion) 0.05% before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board:  

“The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe is outraged that U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill (D-MO), has introduced legislation that specifically targets Indian tribes, yet exempts state universities and other sovereign governments engaged in the very same IPR process.  The double standard that is being introduced by the Senator as a solution for a perceived abuse of the IPR proceedings does nothing to solve the underlying problem. The Tribes authority is inherent and has been reaffirmed through treaties and legislation from the earliest days of the country.    

It is cruelly ironic that Indian Tribes, with the highest unmet health care needs in the entire country, are being attacked for exercising their sovereign obligation to fill gaps in health coverage caused by the federal government’s abject failure to uphold its trust responsibility.  The fact that the Mohawk community is home to three unmitigated EPA Superfund sites that harm the health of the community and surrounding non-Native communities is a stark example of the government’s failure.  Congress shouldn’t double down on its mistakes by denying the Tribe’s sovereign authority in the IPR process.  

As the largest private employer in Northern New York, the Tribe has a responsibility to ensure the livelihood and well-being of its tribal members and its hundreds of non-Native employees. The Tribe remains committed to working with all Members of Congress to discuss how its recent economic diversification efforts benefits the Tribe, its members, and the surrounding communities without harming competition among pharmaceutical companies (both private and generic) or artificially inflating drug prices.” 

##### 

The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribal Council is the duly elected and federally  recognized government of the Saint Regis Mohawk People.

share

Allergan Patent

11/20/2017

article How a Native American tribe came to own one of the world’s most valuable patents
(New York) -- Allergan, the drugmaker behind Botox, is using an unprecedented tactic to protect its valuable patents – angering lawyers and politicians, and...

11/16/2017

article Allergan’s unusual legal tactic attracts political scrutiny
(Washington D.C.) -- “BRAZEN” and “absurd”: Allergan certainly drew a reaction from American lawmakers when it transferred its patents for...

11/14/2017

article Why Is Allergan Partnering with the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe?
(New York) -- The St. Regis Mohawk Reservation, in upstate New York, sits at the U.S. border with Canada, and most of its residents are citizens of both countries, as...

11/13/2017

article Five testimonies from the Allergan-tribe patent hearing
(USA) -- On November 7, the House Judiciary Committee’s subcommittee on IP took part in the “Sovereign Immunity and the Intellectual Property System”...

11/11/2017

article Allergan’s Bold Patent Move Could Transform Pharma Landscape
(New York) -- Pharmaceutical giant Allergan struck a bold and unusual deal to protect its patents on a lucrative eye drug in September. If successful, the maneuver could...

11/7/2017

article IP experts testify before Congress on Allergan tribal patent deal
(Washington D.C.) -- A congressional subcommittee on Tuesday heard testimony from intellectual property experts about the validity of drugmaker Allergan PLC’s...
article Senators question Allergan CEO on tribe patent deal
(Washington D.C.) -- Allergan's unusual deal with the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe to gain protection from certain patent challenges drew intense scrutiny when the drug...
article U.S. senators press Allergan for details on patent deal with tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- A group of U.S. senators on Tuesday asked drugmaker Allergan Plc to produce documents relating to its agreement to transfer patents to a Native...

11/6/2017

article Congress sets date for hearing on Allergan-tribe deal
(Washington D.C.) -- A US House of Representatives committee has called a hearing on the issue of IP rights being owned by entities that claim sovereign immunity. In an...

11/2/2017

article CEO of Botox maker Allergan on Mohawk tribe patent deal: 'It wasn't desperation, it was tenacity'
(New York) -- Allergan's controversial deal with the Saint Regis Mohawk tribe giving the group the patent rights to one of its key drugs was widely misunderstood,...

11/1/2017

article Allergan assuages shareholder fears over losing Restasis patent
(New York) -- Allergan Plc on Wednesday reassured shareholders that it would return to earnings growth in 2019 after losing a major patent ruling last month on its...
article CEO of Botox maker Allergan on Mohawk tribe patent deal: 'It wasn't desperation, it was tenacity'
(New York) -- Allergan's controversial deal with the Saint Regis Mohawk tribe giving the group the patent rights to one of its key drugs was widely misunderstood,...
article Tribal sovereign immunity in patent cases questioned
(Washington D.C.) -- In a creative attempt to shield its patents from invalidity, the pharmaceutical company Allergan, PLC has assigned six patents covering its popular...

10/31/2017

article Pharma industry faces hypocrisy charge over patents
(New York) -- When Allergan transferred patents protecting a $1.5bn eye drug to a Native American tribe last month in an attempt to shield the medicine from generic...
article Drug companies transfer patents to Native American tribes
(USA) -- You may have seen the recent news that a drug company transferred its valuable patents to a Native American tribe in an effort to prevent the patents from being...

10/23/2017

article Allergan Was Correct To Fight The Legal Theft Of Property
(New York) -- Allergan (NYSE:AGN) is an established company with much more on the market than just Restasis. They’ll survive financially even if they lose the...
article Allergan Patent Deal Is No Sham, Tribe Tells PTAB [sub req]
(New York) -- A Native American tribe that acquired patents for Allergan’s blockbuster eye drug Restasis is sharply criticizing generic-drug makers for questioning...

10/20/2017

article Does Claire McCaskill not respect intellectual property, or does she just not like Native Americans?
(Washington D.C.) -- In a fight over the intellectual property of American companies, Sen. Claire McCaskill, D-Mo., has inadvertently stepped onto the third rail of...
article HILTZIK: A judge calls foul on Allergan's attempt to hide its drug patents behind an Indian tribe's sovereignty
(Texas) -- In the annals of cynical corporate subterfuges, it would be hard to top the effort by the drugmaker Allergan to fend off a patent challenge by selling its...
article Labor, consumer groups urge probe of Allergan tribal patent deal
(Washington D.C.) -- Groups representing healthcare providers, consumers and trade unions on Thursday urged the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee to investigate Allergan...
article Senators and court complain of ‘anti-competitive’ transfer of patent rights to American Indian tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- We have previously discussed antitrust implications of pharmaceutical companies’ efforts to maximize patent protection for their drugs....

10/18/2017

article Mohawk tribe sues Amazon and Microsoft in complicated supercomputer patent spat
(New York) -- A Native American tribe and a small computer company have reportedly sued Amazon and Microsoft, claiming that they’re infringing on patents relating to...
article Mohawk tribe, SRC Labs sue Microsoft, Amazon for patent infringement
(New York) -- The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe and SRC Labs joined together to file lawsuits against Microsoft and Amazon, alleging the two tech companies infringed on their...
article Sovereign Immunity and Inter Partes Review
(New York) -- Sovereign immunity refers to the doctrine that the government cannot be sued without its consent. Specifically, the 11th Amendment precludes federal courts...
article Mohawk tribe sues Microsoft, Amazon for patent infringement
(New York) -- The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe, which captured headlines last month for its unusual patent deal with drugmaker Allergan, is doubling down in the patent space...
article Native American tribe holding patents sues Amazon and Microsoft
(New York) -- A Native American tribe sued Amazon.com Inc and Microsoft Corp in federal court in Virginia on Wednesday for infringing supercomputer patents it is holding...

10/17/2017

article Allergan’s unusual deal with a Native American tribe could be backfiring
(New York) -- Allergan, the drugmaker behind Botox, on Monday, had patents on one of its key drugs invalidated by a district court judge. The case was regarding Restasis...
article Judge throws out Allergan patents, criticises Native American tribe deal
(New York) -- A federal judge has thrown out patents protecting Allergan’s blockbuster dry-eye drug Restasis, and has criticised its related deal with a Native...
article Mylan: Allergan’s legal move with tribe reveals “duplicitousness” towards patent system
(Texas) -- Allergan (NYSE:AGN) was dealt a major blow yesterday after a Texas judge ruled that claims to a number of patents for its dry eye drug, Restasis, were invalid...

10/16/2017

article Judge throws out Allergan patent, slams company’s Native American deal
(Texas) -- A federal judge ruled today that patents protecting Allergan's $1.5 billion blockbuster dry-eye drug, Restasis, are invalid due to obviousness.
article One of Allergan's blockbuster drugs was dealt a major legal blow
(Texas) -- Allergan, the drugmaker behind Botox, just had the patents on one of its key drugs invalidated. The case was regarding Restasis, a blockbuster eye drug whose...
article Patents for Restasis Are Invalidated, Opening Door to Generics
(Texas) -- A federal judge in Texas invalidated four key patents for the dry-eye treatment Restasis on Monday, dealing a blow to its manufacturer, Allergan, which had...

10/14/2017

article Mylan Calls Allergan’s Patent Sale to Indian Tribe a ‘Sham’ (sub req)
(New York) -- Generic-drug company Mylan NV has fired back at rival Allergan PLC’s attempt to shield its top-selling eye drug from competition by transferring the...

10/13/2017

article Allergan settles with one of four companies contesting Restasis patent
(New York) -- Allergan Plc said on Thursday it reached a settlement with InnoPharma Inc, one of the four generic drugmakers challenging the patents for its dry eye...

10/12/2017

article Allergan documents due to address patent ‘sham’ question
(New York) -- Allergan has until tomorrow, Friday October 13, to address the question of whether its patent licensing deal with a Native American tribe was a sham.

10/11/2017

article Allergan patent deal with Mohawks was a sham
(Texas) -- Last month, in the midst of post-trial briefing in Allergan’s patent suit against generic drug makers that want to begin selling a version of Allergan...
article Judge wants to know if Allergan’s tribal patent deal is a “sham”
(Texas) -- Last month, the drug company Allergan made news for a deal in which it gave six of its patents to a Native American tribe in order to avoid a patent review...
article Ten big lobbying groups turn their guns on Allergan’s controversial patent gambit
(Washington D.C.) -- Ten of the biggest healthcare lobbying groups in Washington, DC have joined the growing forces lined up against Allergan’s patent gambit...

10/10/2017

article BLOG: Native Americans Set to Save the Patent System
(Washington D.C.) -- As readers of this blog are aware, there has been a great deal of publicity generated by the recent patent sale and assignment by Allergan to the St...

10/9/2017

article How Racism Is Fueling a Pharma Scandal Over a Billion-Dollar Patent
(New York) -- An unprecedented deal between a pharmaceutical company and a Native American tribe has sparked a backlash, including a new bill to prevent an unusual legal...
article Judge Questions Allergan plc Patent Agreement With Mohawk Tribe
(New York) -- A Federal judge raised questions about the legitimacy of Allergan plc Ordinary Shares (NYSE:AGN)’s patent deal with the Native American Mohawk tribe...
article Why Assigning Patents To Native American Tribes To Avoid Inter Partes Review Is Bad Medicine
(New York) -- Since the advent of the America Invents Act (“AIA”), patent practitioners and litigators have had to adjust prosecution, litigation and...
article 'That should be illegal': Lawmakers are taking aim at pharma giant Allergan over an unusual deal with a Native American tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- Allergan, the drugmaker behind Botox, is using a tricky workaround to protect patents on one of its drugs — and lawmakers aren't exactly...
article New bill would end Native American “sovereign immunity” for patents
(Washington D.C.) -- Allergan's move to stop its patents from being reviewed by handing them off to a Native American tribe is winning support from few people...
article ‘That should be illegal’: Lawmakers are taking aim at pharma giant Allergan over an unusual deal with a Native American tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- In September, Allergan struck an unusual deal with the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe to transfer patents of the eye drug Restasis, a move that gives the...

10/8/2017

article Waxman hits out at Allergan patent deal with Mohawk tribe
(New York) -- The architect of landmark legislation that established the system for generic medicines in the US has hit out at Allergan, accusing the drugmaker of...

10/7/2017

article Judge asks if Allergan's patent deal with Mohawk tribe is a 'sham'
(New York) -- Scrutiny of Allergan's unusual patent partnership with a Native American tribe continued to ratchet higher Friday, with a federal judge raising the...
press release Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe Outraged at Senator McCaskill’s Attempt to Abrogate Sovereign Immunity
(New York) -- The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe issued the following statement today in response to legislation introduced by U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill (D-MO) that seeks...

10/6/2017

article Mohawk Tribe 'Outraged' Over Bill That Would Outlaw Patent Deal
(New York) -- The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe says it's "outraged" by a bid to do away with its sovereign immunity in its dealings with a drug company. The...
article Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe Outraged at Senator McCaskill over Sovereign Immunity Bill
(Washington D.C.) -- Yesterday, United States Senator Claire McCaskill (D-MO) introduced legislation that would strip Native American Indian Tribes of the ability to...
article Allergan shows how you can destroy your rep and get mobbed by lawmakers in 4 easy steps
(Washington D.C.) -- First came the onslaught of media reports. Then came the outraged letter from the US Senators followed by the launch of a House probe and a...
article BLOG: A bill to abrogate the sovereign immunity of Indian tribes as a defense in inter partes review of patents
(Missouri) -- My Senator (McCaskill) has introduced S. 1948 titled “A bill to abrogate the sovereign immunity of Indian tribes as a defense in inter partes review...
article Congress probes Allergan’s patent deal with Native American tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- Allergan’s patent-protection deal with the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe is under scrutiny from Congress, as the legislative body begins research...
article Rep. Peter Welch on Allergan’s ‘bold, brazen, bizarre’ patent deal with an American Indian tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) is not mincing words when it comes to Allergan Inc.’s deal with an American Indian tribe geared toward protecting one...
article Senator McCaskill drafts bill in response to Allergan patent maneuver
(Washington D.C.) -- Democratic U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill on Thursday said she drafted a bill stating that tribal sovereign immunity cannot be used to block U.S....

10/5/2017

article Members of Congress Side-Eye Pharma Company for Patent Shenanigans
(Washington D.C.) -- Congress is taking drug company Allergan to task for a bizarre legal scheme that involves using a Native American tribe as a shield against patent...
article Sen. McCaskill unveils unprecedented bill to abrogate tribal sovereign immunity
(Washington D.C.) -- A member of Congress who once generated controversy by going after tribal businesses is wading into hot-button territory with a new bill.
article Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe Outraged at Senator McCaskill’s Attempt to Abrogate Sovereign Immunity
(New York) -- The Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe issued the following statement today in response to legislation introduced by U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill (D-MO) that seeks...

10/4/2017

article Backlash to Allergan's tribal patent deal builds as House lawmakers launch probe
(Washington D.C.) -- After five senators came out against the company's tribal licensing deal and Allergan CEO Brent Saunders took a chance to respond, the drugmaker...
article Congress will investigate drug company that gave its patents to Mohawk tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- Members of Congress want answers about a multinational drug company's deal to save its patents by handing them off to a Native American tribe.

10/3/2017

article More scrutiny for Allergan over Native American tribe deal
(Washington D.C.) -- Scrutiny over Allergan's patent partnership with a Native American tribe is ratcheting higher, with Senator Claire McCaskill late Monday calling...

9/29/2017

article A New Patent Loophole? Paying Off A Native American Tribe To Exploit Its Sovereign Immunity
(New York) -- It’s no secret that large corporate rightholders are constantly seeking ways to protect and extend their monopolies using various legal tactics. In a...
article BLOG: Allergan's Gambit: How To Maneuver Around an Unfriendly Law
(New York) -- Recently, Allergan, the Dublin-based drug company famous for Botox and Restasis, made headlines for entering into an unconventional business deal....
article LEGAL BLOG: Update on Sovereign Immunity as a Defense in Post-Grant Proceedings
(New York) -- In early September the pharmaceutical company Allergan announced a surprising transfer of its patents related to the billion-dollar dry-eye drug Restasis....

9/27/2017

article Allergan deal with Mohawk tribe casts patent shadow
(New York) -- The headquarters of the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe, a Native American community in upstate New York, is an unlikely venue for one of the most controversial...
article Allergan’s controversial patent agreement with an American Indian tribe is worrying investors
(New York) -- Allergan PLC’s unusual patent agreement with a New York state American Indian tribe attracted criticism from observers earlier this month.
article Indian Tribal Sovereign Immunity Asserted in an IPR
(New York) -- The America Invents Act (“AIA”) provides for post grant challenges of U.S. patents in the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (“PTAB”) of...
article Tribe, patents, sovereignty, oh my!
(New York) -- A pharmaceutical company and a tribe in the northeast U.S. are making headlines when it comes to patents and sovereignty. The St. Regis Mohawk Tribe acted...
article U.S. senators want probe of Allergan transfer deal with tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- Four U.S. senators have asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to launch an investigation into a deal drugmaker Allergan Plc struck with a Native...

9/26/2017

article How a NY Indian nation ended up with patent for blockbuster drug
(New York) -- It has been a few weeks since the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe announced a landmark partnership with drug giant Allergan. While some observers call it "...
article Mohawk Nation Exercises Sovereign Immunity in Inter Partes Review
(New York) -- Not unexpectedly, on Friday, the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe (SRMT) filed a motion before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) to have inter partes review...

9/25/2017

article Patent Owner In Apple IPad Suit Has Ties To ND Tribe [sub req]
(North Dakota) -- A patent that Apple Inc. has been accused of infringing with its iPad was transferred to a patent holding company with ties to a Native American tribe...

9/23/2017

article BLOG: Indian Tribe files Motion to Dismiss RESTASIS Patent Challenge based on Sovereign Immunity
(New York) -- Earlier today the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe filed a Motion to Dismiss in six[1] separate inter partes review (IPR) proceedings relating to the Allergan drug...
article Native American tribe moves to dismiss Allergan patent case
(New York) -- A Native American tribe holding patents for drugmaker Allergan Plc (AGN.N) on Friday moved to dismiss a case brought by generic drug company Mylan NV...

9/22/2017

article How the Akwesasne Mohawks ended up with the patent for a blockbuster drug
(New York) -- It's been a few weeks since the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe announced a landmark partnership with drug giant Allergan. Allergan, based in Ireland, makes...

9/19/2017

article How A Partnership Between Drug Giant, Native American Tribe, May Affect Drug Patent Challenges
(New York) -- A drug company and a native tribe in upstate New York have struck a deal. They will use the tribe's sovereign status to enhance the patent protection...

9/17/2017

article Allergan seeks tribe’s help in patent dispute
(New York) -- In a novel arrangement, the pharmaceutical maker Allergan has enlisted the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe to help protect the dry-eye drug Restasis against...
article OP/ED: Allergan patent runaround may be legal, but it's not right
(South Carolina) -- Late last year, at a Forbes magazine health-care conference, I heard Brent Saunders, the chief executive of Allergan, talk about drug prices. He said...

9/16/2017

article To extend a drug patent, one drug company wants to give it to a Native American tribe
(New York) -- It's tough being a pharmaceutical company when your patent rights run out — the generic competition rushes in, and profits go down on a drug that...

9/15/2017

article U.S. senator slams Allergan patent deal with Native-American tribe
(Washington D.C.) -- U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown said on Friday a deal that drugmaker Allergan Plc made with a Native-American tribe to shield patents "rips off consumers...

9/14/2017

article Allergan Avails Itself of Sovereign Immunity
(New York) -- The 11th amendment to the Constitution reads:The judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity,...
article Allergan Deal May Set Stage For More Tribal Patent Pacts
(New York) -- A recent deal struck to shield Allergan PLC’s patents for dry eye medication Restasis behind a New York tribe’s sovereign immunity is drawing...
article Mohawks To The Rescue? Can You Immunize Patents From PTAB Review By Assigning To A Native American Tribe?
(New York) -- In an unusual move to combat the perceived bias in favor of patent challengers at the U.S. Patent Office’s Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB), the...
article Tribal justice? A clever new patent transfer strategy seeks to avoid Patent Office scrutiny
(New York) -- “There is a meadow in my perfect world,” goes the haunting poem that opens the gorgeous, disturbing summer film “Wind River,” which concerns a murder on a...

9/13/2017

article Drug company hands patents off to Native American tribe to avoid challenge
(New York) -- A drug company has found a novel way to avoid challenges to some of its most prized patents: handing them off to a Native American tribe for safe-keeping....
article Mylan attacks Allergan over its Mohawk-allied patent strategy — but the CEO is sticking to his guns
(New York) -- Mylan didn’t wait long before challenging Allergan’s bid to safeguard its patents for its blockbuster eye drug Restasis by flipping the rights...
article Tech entity has tribal patent deal similar to Allergan's
(New York) -- The Native American tribe that agreed to hold patents for the drug company Allergan Plc in an attempt to shield them from U.S. administrative review is...

9/12/2017

article HILTZIK: A legal spat between pharmaceutical companies defines what's wrong with our drug regulations
(California) -- Lawsuits in the pharmaceutical industry are as common as TV ads promoting wonder drugs, never mind the horrific side effects relegated to a breathless,...
article More on Tribal Immunity: Is a Tribal-Owned Patent Immune from IPR Challenge?
(Washington D.C.) -- US Law generally holds that Indian Tribes are “Sovereign Powers” that “possess immunity from suit,” although only “to...
article Native American tribe open to more patent deals with pharma
(New York) -- A Native American tribe says it expects more deals with pharma companies looking to protect patents, following a multi-million dollar deal that could...
article U.S. tribal patent deal could have big impact on generic drug market
(New York) -- A groundbreaking deal between Allergan Plc and a Native American tribe to shield the company’s patents in administrative proceedings could also be...
article Why a Drug Company Is Selling Patents to a Native American Tribe
(New York) -- Some especially strange and unprecedented news broke late last week: Drug company Allergan sold the patent for its medication Restasis to the St. Regis...

9/11/2017

article Allergan Pulls A Fast One
(New York) -- Friday brought news of a drug-company maneuver that I had never heard of, and didn’t even realize was possible. First, a bit of background; the stage...
article Allergan's Patent Loophole Could Be a Huge Gift for Pfizer
(New York) -- The tribe has spoken. On Friday, Allergan announced that the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe now owns all patents for blockbuster dry-eye disease drug Restatis....
article Drug maker ducks patent law by pretending its drugs belong to Mohawk tribe
(New York) -- Corporate titans are adroit at navigating the American legal system to their advantage. When it won’t work to simply outspend their critics and drag...
article St. Regis Mohawk tribe inks landmark deal with drug maker Allergan
(New York) -- The St. Regis Mohawk Tribe here in the North Country is set to receive more than $13 million from the drug-maker Allergan as part of a deal designed to...
article Allergan Patent Deal Isn't Just Unusual. It's Ugly.
(New York) -- Late last year, at a Forbes magazine health-care conference, I heard Brent Saunders, the chief executive of Allergan PLC, talk about drug prices. He said...

9/10/2017

article Allergan Shares Rise on Novel Patent Pact for Restasis
(New York) -- The drugmaker unveiled an agreement that transfers patents for Restasis, Allergan's longstanding dry eye medication, to the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe,...
article Allergan transfers drug patent to Mohawk tribe to sidestep lawsuits
(New York) -- Drugmaker Allergan announced on Friday that it had transferred its patents on a best-selling eye drug to the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe in upstate New York...
article Native American tribe gets Allergan drug rights
(New York) -- Allergan has found an unusual way to shield one of its blockbuster drugs from generic competition. The drug giant, which is defending its intellectual...

visionary sponsor advertisement

sponsor advertisement