States and tribes better off working together in this new Era of Constriction
(Blog) Mark Trahant: States and tribes better off working together in this new Era of Constriction
The new Era of Constriction -- shrinking all levels of government -- is both an opportunity for tribes and a threat.
First, the problem. State and local governments are in deep financial holes. The optimistic view is that state governments have seen the worse and have turned the corner; they are still facing shortages, but far less than a couple of years ago. There are a lot of numbers to back up this argument. State budgets are smaller by some 14 percent, there are fewer employees, and budget deficits have been steadily getting smaller. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities says 24 states are predicting shortfalls of $46 billion for fiscal year 2013, down from $191 billion in fiscal year 2010.
But that optimistic accounting is tempered by a couple of problems. The federal stimulus money is gone. “So even though significant budget gaps remain in 2012, there will be little federal money available to close them,” says the CBPP report, States Continue to Feel Recessions Impact. “As a result, states' final 2012 budgets have contained some of the deepest spending cuts since the start of the recession.”
On top of that, as I wrote last week, future federal budget cuts will cause state revenues to drop even more. And, if that weren’t enough, states have seriously underfunded many longterm obligations such as pensions. One Wall Street analyst, Meredith Whitney (who was right about housing in 2007) predicts hundreds of billions of dollars in debt defaults by local governments.She recently told CNBC that states are in worse financial shape than they were six months ago.
So what is the impact of all of this on Indian Country?
Seattle attorney Gabriel Galanda puts it this way, on the social network, LinkedIn: “Tax-starved states and counties will continue to attempt to extract value from reservation economic development projects, through taxation or otherwise. Tribes must be vigilant in their defense against illegal inter-local cash grabs.”
On Galanda’s blog he writes that Washington state Republicans are proposing to “close” tribal tax loopholes worth $110 million. His message is clear. “Make no mistake about it,” he writes, “the state tax man cometh to Indian Country. Be prepared.”
On the spending side, the most important conflict between tribes and states will be over Medicaid. This is one of those federal programs that is not supposed to be about Indian Country, yet its impact is huge because it represents expanded funding for the Indian health system. But states, not the federal government, write the rules and regulations to pay for Medicaid programs, even though the cost is reimbursed by the federal government for patients within the Indian health system. (A further complication: Both Democrats and Republicans protect the share of Medicaid that pays for nursing home and institutional care, while the debate about the program ends up shifting to serving the “poor” rather than looking at Medicaid as a whole.”)
This is all pretty dark stuff. State budgets represent choices of bleak and bleaker. So what’s the opportunity for tribes?
But tribes (and states) have far more to gain with cooperation over confrontation. Tribes are large employers and contribute to regional economy in huge ways. States should be protecting and enhancing that spirit of enterprise, rather than destroying it with short-sighted attempts to tax. In Idaho, for example, a study by Abelardo Rodriquez of the University of Idaho Extension found that Idaho tribes created some 7,500 jobs (4,500 of those gaming related) with wages near $160 million generating $17 million in property and income tax payments.
If these jobs were created by, say, IBM instead of five Idaho tribes, the state legislature would be falling all over itself to protect this asset. Tribes need to reframe the debate along these lines.
Another opportunity is to reframe Medicaid rules. It’s time to remove states from making rules about the Indian health system and shift this power to tribal governments. The Affordable Care Act already sets out a plan for the Navajo Nation, but as budget tightens, other tribes need to assert authority over Medicaid.
State governments need solutions right now -- and tribal governments could be and should be the unexpected partners. (Next week: Where local governments fit into this puzzle.)
Other Blog Posts by This Author
Mark Trahant: How to stop the sequester: Win the next election
(Washington D.C.) -- A couple of weeks ago I was on Capitol Hill. In between meetings, I sat in the sun and watched tourists come and go. I also saw the First Amendment...
Mark Trahant: The politics of Republican vs. Republican
(Washington D.C.) -- Two years ago President Barack Obama met with House Republicans during their retreat in Baltimore. He said it was important to “visit the...
Mark Trahant: Cheap money: Why the debt-limit fight matters
(Washington D.C.) -- It’s easy to be gloomy about the prospects of the United States government. The country, after all, owes a boat load of money and the...
Mark Trahant: Congress’ fight over status quo means another shutdown of government
(Washington D.C.) -- The Idaho congressional delegation represents the divide that is the Republicans in the U.S. House of Representatives. Rep. Mike Simpson, from...
Mark Trahant: Supreme Court’s affirmation of ‘ObamaCare’ means a fundamentally different debate; Indian Health Care Improvement Act is permanent
(Washington D.C.) -- The entire debate over “ObamaCare” is now fundamentally different. It’s the law of the land that has been upheld by the Supreme...
Mark Trahant: Voter registration at Indian Health clinic is a way to boost number of Native Americans at polls
(Washington D.C.) -- Voting should be easy, almost routine. If it’s election day ... we should vote. It’s that simple because it’s the very foundation...
Mark Trahant: State of the Union, Part 2: A call for votes and resources from America’s first nations
(Washington D.C.) -- The National Congress of American Indians every year releases its “State of Indian Nations,” an alternative prospect for the Congress...
Mark Trahant: State of the Union, Part 1: It’s time to invest in young people
(Washington D.C.) -- Presidents are required to be optimistic.The American people expect it -- and reward those politicians who know their lines. President Barack Obama...
Mark Trahant: Repeal of Affordable Care Act is not a likely election outcome
(Washington D.C.) -- A question for any Republican running for any federal office: If you are successful repealing “ObamaCare,” what happens to the Indian...
Mark Trahant: Health care remains the 2012 election riddle
(Washington D.C.) -- This election ought to be about one issue, a referendum on health care reform. Republicans say it’s about repealing Obamacare. Every candidate...
Mark Trahant: Winning the day: Indian Country’s election year begins now
(Washington D.C.) -- Happy New Year. Or, I should say, happy election year. From now on the national election for president (as well as the house and the senate) shifts...
Mark Trahant: Not a bad federal budget, only consider it as a transition plan
(Washington D.C.) -- I’ve been writing a lot lately about the Era of Contraction -- the shrinking of the federal government -- and what that policy means to Indian...
Mark Trahant: Why the payroll tax fight matters
(Washington D.C.) -- Congress has a long to-do list to complete before the end of the year. It must enact a budget, either a real one, or for most federal agencies, a...
Mark Trahant: President Obama says Indian Country is at a turning point. But heading in what direction?
(Washington D.C.) -- Politicians are required to be optimistic. It’s the first tool in their bag. And a president of the United States is even more optimistic than...
Mark Trahant: ‘Big Deal’ is the coming federal budget cuts
(Washington D.C.) -- Last December hundreds of American Indian and Alaska Native leaders traveled to Washington, D.C. for the second White House Tribal Nations...
Mark Trahant: Congressional legacy: A failure to govern
(Washington D.C.) -- A simple statement from the two co-chairs of the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction. “After months of hard work and intense...
Mark Trahant: Whooshing past the strict congressional deadline for difficult budget choices
(Washington D.C.) -- The United States Congress is debating two important principles. There is the idea that a strict deadline forces action. (Or, more accurately, as...
Mark Trahant: Why vote? Because even imperfect elections still matter
(Washington D.C.) -- We know democracy’s slogan: “Elections matter.” Or if that doesn’t work, draw on so many other oft-repeated phrases that...
Mark Trahant: “Termination, Self-Determination and now Contraction: Navigating a new era.”
(Oregon) -- Thank you for inviting me to speak this morning. This is a particular honor for me. When I was a kid I used to spend time here in Portland with a man I...
Mark Trahant: Remember health care reform? Law, funding remain on separate and unequal tracks
(Washington D.C.) -- Remember health care reform? The Republican presidential candidates all promise repeal just as soon as they win the White House. But we ought to ask...
Mark Trahant: Budget cuts will repeat a tragic history
(Washington D.C.) -- Tribal leaders went to Capitol Hill last week to make the case to protect American Indian and Alaska Native programs from the deep federal spending...
Mark Trahant: Looking at the federal budget as metaphor
(Washington D.C.) -- There are many ways to look at America’s shift into the Era of Contraction. Budget numbers tell part of the story. Words of elected leaders...
Mark Trahant: A road less traveled, a journey through the Era of Contraction
(Idaho) -- I drove across the Northwest this past weekend. A 1,700-mile trip from Idaho to Seattle, returning via rural roads in Washington, and freeways in Idaho and...
Mark Trahant: Era of Contraction (like termination) begins slowly; tribes have time to find new resources
(Washington D.C.) -- It’s nearly impossible to know when a new political era has begun for certain. Congress enacted House Resolution 108 on August 1, 1953,...
Mark Trahant: President must sell a complicated jobs program to a simple-minded Congress
(Washington D.C.) -- President Barack Obama must sell a complex idea to a Congress that prides itself on simplicity. This Congress, namely the House Republicans, were...
Mark Trahant: It sounds reasonable: Just cap the spending. Only reality is harmful to people & budgets
(Washington D.C.) -- It sounds reasonable: Why not just cap federal spending? Make every agency operate with the money that’s already there. This notion has common...
Mark Trahant: Administration proposes to ‘double down’ on federal spending cuts
(Washington D.C.) -- So far, most of the government’s austerity movement has been theoretical. We know the federal budget is shrinking, but the evidence of that...
Mark Trahant: A hell of a way to run a country ... full speed traveling in different directions
(Washington D.C.) -- It’s a hell of a way to run a country. Last week a federal appeals court ruled at least one major provision of the the Affordable Care Act is...
Mark Trahant: The Federal Budget Is The March of Folly
(Washington D.C.) -- The late historian Barbara Tuchman described the ineptness of government decision-making in her book, The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam. She...
Mark Trahant: Yea! The President and Congress found compromise in a deadline deal ... now let the real debate begin
(Washington D.C.) -- There’s nothing like deadline to produce a deal: The president and congressional leaders reached an agreement over the weekend to increase the...
Mark Trahant: Dental health therapist program is the essence of excellence and self-determination
(Alaska) -- Conan Murat has a tough schedule. About every other week he packs up a portable dental office, checks his groceries, sleeping bags and other supplies, then...
Mark Trahant: Summer reading add perspective to current debates about American Indian policy
(Idaho) -- The debt ceiling negotiations are deep underground. While there’s plenty of action on the surface, posturing, mostly, there are also quiet talks about...
Mark Trahant: Country’s problems are too complex for 140 character answers or political slogans
(Washington D.C.) -- Last week President Barack Obama held his first town hall on Twitter. A really great idea and I plunged in with this question: “#AskObama...
Mark Trahant: Throw away the old playbook: Tribes and counties are better off working together as neighbors
(Washington D.C.) -- Idaho’s Bannock County is considering an ordinance that would create an “overlay” zoning district on the Fort Hall Indian...
Mark Trahant: States and tribes better off working together in this new Era of Constriction
(Washington D.C.) -- The new Era of Constriction -- shrinking all levels of government -- is both an opportunity for tribes and a threat. First, the problem....
Mark Trahant: How bad is the economy? We’re halfway to a lost decade
(Washington D.C.) -- How bad is this economy? Former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers wrote in The Financial Times this week that the United States is now halfway to...
Mark Trahant: Where are Indian Country’s jobs?
(Washington D.C.) -- Last week the Bureau of Labor Statistics started a frenzy when it released its latest job report, showing that only 54,000 jobs were added to the...
Mark Trahant: Will Indian Country be excited by President Obama’s reelection campaign in 2012?
(Washington D.C.) -- Canada just finished its national elections and the governing Conservative Party expanded its majority in parliament. Last week Prime Minister...
Mark Trahant: Republican divide about Medicare should reopen the health care reform debate
(Washington D.C.) -- Republican Party unity on the issue of a massive restructuring of Medicare and Medicaid (if there is such a thing) ended this weekend. Presidential...
Mark Trahant: Tribes should develop foreign policies to counter U.S. policy of contraction
(Washington D.C.) -- Nobel winning economist Joseph Stiglitz is trying to change the national debate about the deficit, the role of government and the impact of those...
Mark Trahant: Debt limit debate matters to Indian Country
(Washington D.C.) -- Sometimes it’s easy for Indian Country to ignore the huge challenges facing the United States. After all, there are so many immediate and...
Mark Trahant: The family math doesn’t work when it costs $100 to fill-up a pickup truck
(USA) -- A few weeks ago Bloomberg News reported that Saudia Arabia is investing $100 billion in renewable energy sources. In other words the country with the largest...
Mark Trahant: There are a lot of tall tales told about taxes
(Washington D.C.) -- Tall tales are fun. Most of us love the story about the day we scored perfect on a test, caught the biggest fish or won a bunch of cash at the...
Mark Trahant: Bringing stories about sex abuse in Alaska Native communities into the light
(Alaska) -- It’s trite to write that winter days are short this far north. And it is remarkable watching the sun skate through the sky in such a hurry to disappear...
Mark Trahant: Ryan proposes a fundamental change to Medicaid -- and it would be bad
(Washington D.C.) -- The national budget debate is multi-directional. Most of the story, so far, has centered on this year’s federal spending, basically how to...
Mark Trahant: A year after health care reform the discourse of termination returns in the battle of ideas
(Washington D.C.) -- Just over a year ago President Barack Obama signed the health care reform bill into law, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. That...
Mark Trahant: We’re not broke ... and we must invest in young people or the old folks will lose
(Washington D.C.) -- Google the phrase, “we can’t afford,” and some 209 million results pop up that capture our Great Public Debate. Articles range...
Mark Trahant: Japan reminds us about the inevitability of chaos
(Idaho) -- Like most people I watched the events in Japan unfold on cable and through Facebook throughout the weekend. It’s great to see posts from friends and...
Mark Trahant: Contraction policy will cost Indian Country thousands of good paying jobs
(Washington D.C.) -- Finally the economy seems to be creating jobs again. Last week a federal jobs survey showed an increase in 222,000 private sector jobs, a full year...
Mark Trahant: Test of values: Strategies for Native communities to weather Congress
(Washington D.C.) -- This week represents, perhaps, the most important week of lobbying for tribal nations since the end of the termination era. At a variety of meetings...
Mark Trahant: What is ‘Plan B’ for tribes if there is a federal government shutdown?
(Washington D.C.) -- Is there a Plan B? That is the question tribes, Indian organizations and government agencies should be asking -- and answering because it...
visionary sponsor advertisement
Most Popular Stories